An independent regulatory commission has found that officials made a “clear and obvious error” when they sent off Everton’s Dominic Calvert-Lewin in an FA Cup tie at Crystal Palace. The incident occurred on 4th January during a third round tie, with the commission unanimously agreeing that Calvert-Lewin’s tackle on Nathaniel Clyne did not constitute serious foul play.
The commission explained its decision on the Football Association (FA) website, stating that the tackle lacked force, speed, and intensity, and did not endanger the safety of the opponent. As a result, it did not meet the threshold required for a red card. After considering guidance from the referee advisory panel, the commission unanimously concluded that the referee had made a clear and obvious error.
In the 79th minute of the match, Calvert-Lewin was shown a red card for a sliding tackle on Clyne. Despite the referee initially allowing play to continue, the Video Assistant Referee (VAR) advised the referee to review the incident on the pitchside monitor, leading to the red card decision.
After Everton’s appeal, the dismissal was overturned by the FA on 9th January.
During a commission hearing, Everton argued that Calvert-Lewin’s tackle exhibited a high degree of control and was not reckless or forceful. The three-man commission agreed with Everton’s assessment, stating that the challenge was “at most reckless” and did not meet the criteria for a red card for serious foul play.
The incident has sparked debate among football fans and experts, with many criticizing the role of VAR in the decision-making process. This case highlights the ongoing controversy surrounding VAR and its impact on the game.
Overall, the situation serves as a reminder of the complexities and challenges involved in refereeing and decision-making in football, particularly in high-stakes cup competitions like the FA Cup.